When Audemars Piguet introduced the Code 11.59 in 2019, it sparked one of the most intense debates in recent watch history: should the traditional Royal Oak have a contemporary companion? Now several years on, both watches have found their audiences. For super clone buyers, the question remains: which AP should you buy? At Grand Watch Club, we help you navigate this decision.
The Royal Oak: 50 Years of Heritage
The Royal Oak needs no introduction — it is one of the most influential watch designs in history, created by Gerald Genta in 1972 and now celebrating its 50th anniversary as a true icon. Its octagonal bezel, tapisserie dial, and integrated bracelet have been imitated, celebrated, and collected worldwide. The Royal Oak 15500ST is the current steel flagship — 41mm, Calibre 4302, available in blue, grey, white, and other tapisserie dial options.
The Royal Oak’s strengths as a super clone subject are clear: it is instantly recognizable, universally appreciated in watch circles, and carries half a century of cultural significance. When someone who knows watches sees a Royal Oak on your wrist, they know exactly what they’re looking at. This recognition factor is part of what makes the Royal Oak so compelling. Learn more about the history in our AP Royal Oak history guide.
The Code 11.59: AP’s Modern Statement
The Code 11.59 is AP’s attempt to create a contemporary companion to the Royal Oak — a round-cased, modern-sensibility watch that uses case construction techniques and complications to compete at the highest level without relying on the Royal Oak’s heritage. The case construction is genuinely extraordinary: a round outer bezel contains an octagonal middle case, which itself encloses a round movement — a Russian doll of geometric forms that only becomes apparent under close examination.
The Code 11.59 is designed for those who want AP quality and in-house movements with a more contemporary aesthetic. It’s less immediately recognizable as an AP watch to the general public, which its buyers consider a feature rather than a bug — it’s a watch for connoisseurs rather than brand-signaling. Initial critical reception was mixed, but the Code 11.59 has found a devoted following among collectors who appreciate technical watchmaking over heritage.
Super Clone Comparison: Which is More Compelling?
For super clone buyers, the Royal Oak presents a clearer case: the tapisserie dial, integrated bracelet, and octagonal bezel are visually distinctive enough that the super clone carries the Royal Oak’s instant recognition. The Code 11.59’s visual complexity is harder to replicate faithfully in super clone form, and its audience is smaller — reducing the recognition factor that makes luxury watch ownership socially rewarding for many buyers. Our recommendation: start with the Royal Oak if you want maximum impact. The Code 11.59 is for collectors building beyond their first super clone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Why was the Code 11.59 controversial?
A: The Code 11.59 was criticized at launch for its dial design and perceived lack of differentiation from other AP offerings. Some felt its price was unjustified without the Royal Oak’s heritage. However, the watchmaking quality has been widely praised, and opinions have softened significantly since 2019.
Q: Can you tell the Code 11.59 is an AP?
A: The Code 11.59 has the AP logo but lacks the Royal Oak’s immediately distinctive octagonal bezel. Many people unfamiliar with AP would not recognize it, whereas the Royal Oak is globally recognizable.
Q: Is the Royal Oak or Code 11.59 more expensive?
A: Comparable steel references are similarly priced at retail, both in the $25,000-30,000 range. On the secondary market, the Royal Oak commands a significantly higher premium due to demand imbalance.
Make your choice — and own it. Explore our super clone luxury watch collection at Grand Watch Club. Free worldwide shipping, 1-year warranty on every purchase.
Why Choose Our Premium Timepieces?
When exploring the world of luxury horology, finding the perfect balance between craftsmanship and value is essential. At Grand Watch Club, we specialize in offering meticulously assembled pieces that honor the original specifications down to the microscopic level. Whether you are looking for a robust Rolex for daily wear, an elegant Patek Philippe for formal events, or a sporty Audemars Piguet, our collection ensures uncompromised quality. Every piece undergoes rigorous quality control, ensuring water resistance, power reserve stability, and aesthetic perfection before it reaches your wrist.
Explore our full range of collections and discover why enthusiasts trust us for their most important wrist companions. From the intricate movements to the flawless case finishing, our commitment to excellence remains unmatched in the industry.